Trang chủInternational FootballIndonesia coach compared to Amorim at Man United: Why could 'Garuda' only draw?
Indonesia coach compared to Amorim at Man United: Why could 'Garuda' only draw?
Trận hòa 0-0 với Malaysia khiến Indonesia bị chuyên gia Justinus Lhaksana chỉ trích chiến thuật của HLV John Herdman, ví như thời kỳ Man United dưới Ruben Amorim. Tuy nhiên, Indonesia vẫn xếp thứ hai bảng A với 4 điểm sau 2 trận. Key facts: - Ngày 30/9/2026, Coach Justin trên kênh YouTube cá nhân so sánh lối chơi Indonesia với “sự hủy hoại” của MU thời Amorim. - Indonesia hòa Malaysia 0-0, có 4 điểm và xếp nhì bảng A FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026, kém Malaysia ở hiệu số bàn thắng. - Thom Haye bị xếp vào vai trò chạy và pressing thay vì hộ công tự do; đây là điểm mấu chốt trong chỉ trích. - Thủ môn Maarten Paes cản nhiều cơ hội nguy hiểm, nhưng thẻ đỏ phút 37 khiến Indonesia chơi thiếu người phần lớn trận đấu. Nguồn: VIVA, ngày 30/9/2026 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Related Q&A: - Hỏi: Indonesia có nguy cơ bị loại ở bảng A không? Đáp: Không, với 4 điểm sau 2 trận và chỉ kém Malaysia về hiệu số, Indonesia vẫn nắm quyền tự quyết ở các lượt còn lại. - Hỏi: Thom Haye sẽ được bố trí ra sao ở trận tới? Đáp: Nếu HLV Herdman đáp ứng chỉ trích, Haye có thể trở lại vai trò hộ công tự do; nếu án treo giò từ thẻ đỏ được xác nhận, đội phải tìm phương án thay thế. - Hỏi: So sánh với Man United của Amorim có xác đáng? Đáp: Chỉ mang tính ẩn dụ; bối cảnh câu lạc bộ khác đội tuyển quốc gia, và Indonesia vẫn đứng nhì bảng.
As the final whistle at Gelora Bung Karno faded, the 0-0 draw with Malaysia opened a debate far bigger than a single point. Analyst Justinus Lhaksana, known as Coach Justin, compared Indonesia's national team to the "destruction era" of Manchester United under Ruben Amorim. The comparison was so sharp that VIVA covered it as a media event, and fans immediately split into camps.
The context is specific: Indonesia had just finished their second Group A match of the FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026, drawing 0-0 at home. After two matches they have 4 points and sit second, behind Malaysia only on goal difference. In terms of results, that is an acceptable start. But the performance was enough to anger analysts.
Coach Justin did not oppose John Herdman's right to choose a system. He said on his personal YouTube channel: "You want to play any system, that's free. But please field players according to their capabilities." That is the core of the criticism: the problem is not a 3-4-3 or a 4-2-3-1, it is that Thom Haye – described as the team's only truly creative player – was turned into a runner and high-presser instead of operating as a free playmaker behind the striker.
According to Coach Justin, Indonesia's attack became too predictable: the ball was pushed wide, crosses were flung into the box, and the distance between lines was too large. In gaming terms, the team had put the wrong runes on their carry – high stats, wrong role. But the real issue is simpler: a national team filled with players based overseas, with limited training time, can hardly execute a system demanding high tactical cohesion.
However, reading the full analysis, there is a paradox: Coach Justin also praised Indonesia's defensive discipline and goalkeeper Maarten Paes, who denied "several golden chances" for Malaysia. Is Indonesia really "destroyed"? Good defence, blunt attack – that is an imbalanced team, not a broken one. The catastrophic framing of the headline is overstated compared with the standings.
Few mention another detail: in the 37th minute, a player was sent off. VIVA has not confirmed whether it was Thom Haye. If it was Haye, Indonesia played more than half the match with ten men. In that case, the 0-0 cannot be used as evidence of a failed attacking scheme; it looks more like a result built to protect the game. Herdman may have prioritised defensive stability after the red card, and every "monotone" criticism should be discounted by game state.
Look at the table again. Four points from two matches, second in the group, Indonesia still control their own destiny. The football labelled "destruction" is in a very realistic position to advance. Media pressure is high, but the points tally is not a crisis. If Malaysia lead Indonesia on goal difference, it simply means Indonesia need to score more in the remaining matches – exactly the area under attack.
The biggest blind spot is this: without Paes's saves, the score would not have stayed 0-0. Reliance on a goalkeeper is hard to repeat. Clean sheets built on one man's reflexes are rarely sustainable. Malaysia created the better chances – that is the real warning sign. Haye being misused is an issue to correct, not a reason to tear up the whole tactical plan.
Conversely, Coach Justin's criticism could become the necessary wake-up call. Three falls, one flash of speed, a lifetime as a storyteller – for a team accumulating points, an empty summer is not necessarily defeat; it can be the trophy that lights up the year. But for that to happen, Herdman must answer one question: will Thom Haye be unlocked in the next match, or will he remain trapped in a pressing role?
The script is the map; emotion is the real flash. Indonesia does not need a revolution. They simply need the right people in the right roles, so that the map matches the actual strength. If they manage that, the 0-0 draw with Malaysia will be just a dull chapter in a story that still has every chance of being rewritten.
Cầu thủ liên quan
Bài đề xuất
Seventeen Saplings in Malang and the Two Hidden Money Pipelines of Indonesian Football2026-09-22
Sindh Property Tax Reform: Data-Governance Lessons for Football Administration2026-09-29
Four English Clubs Chase Alexander-Arnold: Mourinho and Real Madrid’s Leverage2026-10-21
Between the Skyline and the Indictment: When Urban Climbers Walked the Runway2026-09-15
Georgia Stanway - England Women's Unstoppable Warrior on the World Cup Qualification Journey2026-10-15
Vietnamese Football in 2026: A Full Picture from V-League to the World Cup Dream2026-10-07
Bài đề xuất
The Death of a 16-Year-Old Persib Supporter at Pakansari: The Truth Lies Outside the Stands2026-10-27
"Lincoln Lost 2-0 Because They Don't Know How to Play Football" – When a 25-Second Goal Is Just the Perfect Trap2026-10-18
The Yellow Card in Liège: With Arda Güler Absent, Turkey Faces a Creative Crossroads2026-10-04
Brian Brobbey Hamstring Injury: Sunderland Lose Their Main Striker for Brighton Clash as Regis Le Bris Insists 'It Is Nothing Serious'2026-10-08
Gaps in Football's Data Supply Chain: When an Analysis Grid Is Full of Cells but Empty of Numbers2026-10-03
Gasperini Keeps Dybala and Molina in Rome Before a Heavy Fixture Block: Reading a Squad Decision Beneath the Emotion2026-10-06
Bài đề xuất
The Indonesia–Thailand Final and the ID-Gated Ticket: A Governance Revolution in Disguise2026-10-03
Logistical Crisis at the 2026 Asian Games and Nagoya Mayor's Apology2026-10-01
Penta, the Money in the Bank Briefcase, and the Gap Between a Nudge and a Championship2026-10-20
Aubameyang's Five Goals and an Unverified Record: When the Number Outruns the File2026-09-14
When the Data Sheet Is Empty, the Match Is Still There2026-10-04
The Empty Report and Sports Analysis's Confession2026-09-30
